It’s to be 55 years since Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer an initial premiered ~ above NBC, and watching the lovely TV unique is tho a Christmastime legacy for countless families. 

You couldn’t ask because that a much more inspiring corridor of outsiders 보다 Rudolph, wannabe dentist/elf Hermey, and everyone’s favourite prospector, Yukon Cornelius. After ~ being actors out through their corresponding tribes, the trio transforms to each other for companionship. 

During their travels with the north Pole, lock accidentally floor on the Island of Misfit Toys, whereby those that are damaged or unwanted go come live till they can discover a boy who will love them.

You are watching: What was wrong with the doll on the island of misfit toys

Residents incorporate a jack-in-the-box called Charlie, a spotted elephant, a choo-choo train v square wheel on the caboose, a water pistol that shoots jelly, a bird the doesn’t fly, a cowboy that rides one ostrich, and a watercraft that can’t remain afloat. 


One concern that has plagued the stop motion animation classic because that years is why the doll, recognized as Dolly for Sue come some, is ~ above the island. She never ever reveals what’s "wrong" with her, and nothing is physically off around her appearance. It took until 2005 for fans to finally get an answer.

We an initial see Dolly for Sue — "the sort that will also say 'How carry out you do?'" — during "The many Wonderful work of the Year," which introduces the audience come the island’s lonely, yet hopeful inhabitants.

Though Dolly appears joyful transparent the song, producer Arthur Rankin Jr. Revealed in an interview with the save on computer of American tv that she finished up ~ above the island because of depression and low self-esteem. Yikes, that’s heavy.


"I constantly say, well, she has actually psychiatric problems. She to be under the treatment of an analyst," Arthur admitted. He elaborated ~ above that point in a 2007 chat v NPR’s "Wait Wait… Don’t phone call Me," stating that Dolly felt unloved ~ being abandoned by she owner (who to be presumably Sue).

Dolly’s "issues" were first hinted in ~ on the Dolly because that Sue Stuffins sold by CVS in 1998. A sign attached to her body read: "I’m a small rag doll who simply wants a friend. Ns think that will aid my damaged heart mend."

Arthur additionally revealed the the secret surrounding Dolly’s visibility on the island stems native the truth that she to be a last-minute enhancement to the broadcast. The producers felt they needed a misfit toy that young girls could relate to (remember, it was a different time back then).

See more: Can You Microwave Styrofoam Take Out Boxes, Can You Microwave Styrofoam Takeout Boxes

As the special underwent revisions over the years, Dolly got an ext screen time and also lines, making her lack of a physical defect more apparent. 


Two years prior to his death, Arthur was asked about what makes Rudolph timeless. "I really don’t have an answer to that," the confessed. "I think because it to be the very first special the its kind… i think that, in trying to find something to watch for Christmas, parents put their youngsters in former of the television.

"And as the audience grew, therefore did the kids that watched it," that added. "They grew up to come to be mothers. And also they prospered up to end up being grandmothers! and also they also put their children and also grandchildren in prior of the television set… To numerous people, Rudolph way Christmas."