Thanksgiving is quick approaching and you’ve acquired all her meals believed out, the just thing absent is the pie. Exactly how soon have the right to you make it, and also how long have the right to it stay in the fridge ?

Does pumpkin pie have to be refrigerated ? You’ve it seems to be ~ them top top shelves in supermarkets and also they didn’t it seems to be ~ cold. And if you decide to purchase a pre-made one, execute you should refrigerate that too ? exactly how long is it an excellent for ?

No one ever said Thanksgiving or any big holiday is simple to chef for. Specifically if you’ve got extended family comes over, or just a large immediate family. Several mouths mean lots of food, and that way carefully planning what and also when to cook.

You are watching: How long is pumpkin pie good for in the fridge

Hopefully we’ll be able to ease your mind, and tell you whatever you need to know around pumpkin pie front of time. Therefore let’s begin with even if it is it demands to continue to be in the refrigerator or not.


Table the Contents

Why pumpkin pie requirements to cool down

Does pumpkin pie need to be refrigerated ?

Yes, pumpkin pie requirements to be refrigerated, otherwise it have the right to go bad. ~ all, the pie filling is a type of custard made with eggs, milk, sugar, spices, and also pumpkin puree.

We introduce you let the pie cool at room temperature for a few hours after acquisition it the end of the oven. Then, you should location plastic pave on the peak to store it from taking in smells indigenous the fridge. Placed it in the fridge, and it must be great for 3-4 days.

Of course, if you’re baking the pie on Thanksgiving work you have the right to serve that as soon as it’s cooled down. If you’re very an excellent at multitasking then you deserve to probably pull that off. If not, then you’re most likely going to bake the pie the day before and also keep it chilled till needed.

Read also: Pumpkin Pie filling VS Pumpkin Puree 

Why are store to buy pumpkin pies not refrigerated ?

The main reason store bought pies (of any kind) space not refrigerated is due to the fact that they save preservatives that make castle shelf-stable. This method that you deserve to leave lock on the respond to overnight, and they will certainly still be good for a couple of days. Or at least until the best-by day printed top top the label.

Homemade pies space not shelf-stable, castle can’t be. They have dairy and also eggs, which spoil an extremely quickly. Even if keep bought pies room safe to leave on the counter, us recommend you placed them in the fridge.

This will keep them safe to eat no matter what, and you can include a couple of more days come the best-by date.

How long have the right to pumpkin pie sit out ?

Homemade pumpkin pie shouldn’t sit out for an ext than 12 hours. 4 to six hrs is the recommended time come let a fresh pie cool off and also reach room temperature.

The much more you leaving it, the more likely you are to acquire a spoiled pie. Store-bought pie isn’t as sensitive and also can it is in left the end for a few days.

Why pumpkin pie requirements to cool down

Let’s talk around pumpkin pie and also why it needs to cool down. Actually this applies to any custard pie, favor a lemon curd pie or a vanilla tart.

The whole suggest of the pie is to get the custard come set, and thus come to be edible. You cannot bake the custard till it’s collection in the oven, because residual warmth in the pie will chef it also further. Not only that, but a cracked custard is generally the result of one overbaked pie.

This is why the pie needs to be contempt jiggly in the facility when you take it it the end of the oven. In the following hour or for this reason the residual warm will chef the custard and also you’ll be left with a smooth, perfectly baked pie.

The best means to make sure your pie comes out perfect is to turn off the oven when the center is tho a little bit jiggly. Jiggly, not wet and sloshing ! Then, leaving the stove door ajar through the pie inside. This does two things.

First, the residual heat from the cooktop will cook the pie further.

Second, you’re no exposing hot pie to cold air ideal away. Therefore you have less the a possibility of gaining a cracked custard.

Can you eat pumpkin pie appropriate out of the cooktop ?

If you were to slice right into a pumpkin pie as soon as it’s still hot, you’d gain a mess. The center would just melt or autumn apart, and also you’d gain a quite unsightly pie.

Not just that, but the custard won’t be totally cooked, or set. You additionally risk cracked or deflating the custard an ext than necessary.

In short please it is in patient and also wait because that the pie to cool down. If you like you pie warm, just let that cool for around 2 hours.

Is pumpkin pie served heat or cold ?

That is totally up come you. Most folks finish up eating the pie cold, since it’s refrigerated, since it’s do the day before. Even when it’s made the day-of, the still needs to cool down and also most folks like making the in the morning, for this reason it has actually plenty of time come cool.

In a way, it’s better to eat pumpkin pie cold, due to the fact that in basic sweet foods taste better cold. There’s additionally the fact that the flavors will develop an ext in the hours after the pie is baked. The same way a curry is much better the following day, than immediately after cooking.

However if you desire to sere your pie warm, friend still have to let the cool after removing native the oven. Only let the cool for around 2 hours, and also then it will certainly still it is in warm.

If your pie has currently cooled turn off completely, you can gently microwave the on low (not medium, no high) because that a few minutes. If friend use also high a setting you’ll burn the outside and the center will it is in lukewarm at best.

How long is pumpkin pie great for ?

In the fridge pumpkin pie deserve to last approximately 4 work after baking. The being said, us recommend friend eat the pie within 2 days, due to the fact that the seasonings will go off conveniently afterwards.

If her pie is home-made and on the counter, girlfriend shouldn’t keep it the end for an ext than 12 hours. Girlfriend won’t need to throw the out, however you risk it begging a monster flavor. It’s best to refrigerate the after it’s cooled, therefore after around 4-6 hours.

And in the situation of save bought pie, you have the right to keep it for as long as the best-by day says. If you placed it in the fridge, you can push a few days previous the published date.

Finally, if you’re planning on freeze the pie, it have to only be retained for around a month, two maybe. You might be disappointed as soon as you take it it the end though. The custard won’t be all that impressive in texture, yet the flavor should be the same.

How have the right to you phone call if pumpkin pie is negative ?

The an initial way come tell your pumpkin pie’s gone bad is to smell it. In fact, you could even smell it beforehand. There’s pumpkin, milk, and also eggs in there. All three of those smell terrible when they go bad.

Another point to look because that is extreme moisture on the peak of the custard. If it’s starting to acquire pools the water (not the ones native plastic pave on top) and also it’s separating, it’s ideal to throw it out.

Obviously, if you see tiny specks the mold (white or blue), there’s no suggest in maintaining it.

And finally, if you recognize you baked the pie Monday morning and also you’re opening the fridge Friday evening, don’t also think around the pie. It’s already lost the flavor and also most likely the texture as well.

Can you do pumpkin pie the day prior to Thanksgiving ?

Yes, you can make pumpkin pie the day prior to Thanksgiving, also two days before if you’re a an extremely busy cook. Pumpkin pie will save for as long as 4 job in the fridge, however we recommend eating it in ~ 2 work of baking.

You have the right to mask any type of imperfections v some whipped cream, and/or sprinkle part extra cinnamon top top top.

See more: Do Dogs Get Cramps On Their Period Or Menstrual Cramps Like Humans Do

If you’ve got any type of other food curiosities be certain to examine the related write-ups below, we’re constantly adding much more food facts to make your life that much easier.